My Boat Anchor

Hamish

Active Member
Was never looking for another muzzle loader, the cheap, plastic stock inline was very accurate and all I needed for ML season. But, perusing the rack at my hole in wall LGS the Square & Compasses grabbed my attention, then, the fact that it was correct handed kind of smacked me in the face. Had to have it.

IMG_6483.jpeg

IMG_6482.jpegIMG_6480.jpegIMG_6479.jpegIMG_6484.jpeg

It’s .54, definitely *not* swamped, and at 42 inches, a bit heavy for free hand firing. The sights, though very fine T/C, and very good for hunting and target work, certainly lack period aesthetic. The patch box release needs help, I don’t much care for the design. And, to be quite honest, I prefer brass accoutrements. But, still and all, it’s a very fine rifle. I’ve not been able to track down the maker so far.

If I could wave a magic wand, I think cutting the barrel to 32” would make it much more shootable, and I can’t help but wonder if I would like it better as a flinter. Dovetail in a proper set of sights, finish coning and star’ing the muzzle. Have the 12” cut off made into a pistol, and live happily ever after.

And then I wonder about molesting what probably shouldn’t be molested,,,,,,I’ve talked to Ian preliminarily about looking at it, but I’m struggling physically at the moment, I won’t be down your way until probably Spring. Meanwhile, I would appreciate any thoughts about my “predicament”. :rolleyes::rofl:

Rich
 
Last edited:
That's a bit of eye candy!

While the sights might not be what would be expected on a longrifle, they will make it easier to adjust for sighting in.

As for flint vs percussion, that likely is doable with not much fuss.

Cut the barrel? Not just no, but HELL NO!
 
Was never looking for another muzzle loader, the cheap, plastic stock inline was very accurate and all I needed for ML season. But, perusing the rack at my hole in wall LGS the Square & Compasses grabbed my attention, then, the fact that it was correct handed kind of smacked me in the face. Had to have it.

View attachment 60995

View attachment 60996View attachment 60997View attachment 60998View attachment 60999

It’s .54, definitely *not* swamped, and at 42 inches, a bit heavy for free hand firing. The sights, though very fine T/C, and very good for hunting and target work, certainly lack period aesthetic. The patch box release needs help, I don’t much care for the design. And, to be quite honest, I prefer brass accoutrements. But, still and all, it’s a very fine rifle. I’ve not been able to track down the maker so far.

If I could wave a magic wand, I think cutting the barrel to 32” would make it much more shootable, and I can’t help but wonder if I would like it better as a flinter. Dovetail in a proper set of sights, finish coning and star’ing the muzzle. Have the 12” cut off made into a pistol, and live happily ever after.

And then I wonder about molesting what probably shouldn’t be molested,,,,,,I’ve talked to Ian preliminarily about looking at it, but I’m struggling physically at the moment, I won’t be down your way until probably Spring. Meanwhile, I would appreciate any thoughts about my “predicament”. :rolleyes::rofl:

Rich
I have a .40 penn style,,and it has all the working tools,inletted,into it.
Had a fellow traveling man,build it for me.
 
I have a similar rifle, not nearly as well done, but like yours is sort of a fantasy piece. The heavy, straight barrels, finger hook on the trigger guard, ornate barrel pin escutcheons, and "heavy" architecture speak to a post-golden-age style, 1820-1840, possibly Ohio, but the patch box is 1800 give or take ten years. The buttplate return extension is a much, much older style and being added on as it has is really the only thing that doesn't work for me.

For practical purposes, what you have is a modern "chunk gun", for shooting itty bitty groups from prone, over a log. It has the sights and mass for that age-old "benchrest" competition style.

If it were mine, I would fit ro it and polish bright a large Siler flint lock, replace the percussion drum with a coned flash hole liner, and finish filing in a wedding band on the buttplate return and try to do something to make the extension somehow look like it belongs in the same century with the buttplate.

I would NOT shorten it nor would I cone or radius out the grooves at the muzzle. A chunk gun needs a gentle, highly polished radius crown for starting a tight patch/ball combination without cutting the patch, but nothing more.

I still have three sealed letters of recommendation and an application complete except for one question that three decades on I still cannot answer honestly and be granted admission. The "Grand Architect" is many thjngs to many people, but nothing more than (to quote Albert Einstein) "absurd egotism" to me.
 
Thank you Ian, I suspected it built for chunk matches. I shall leave it as is and over the Winter study up on the conversion, by Spring I’ll see if I’m still interested in changing over,,, ,at some point I’ll try to get some good pics of the patch box release for some advice on how to change/modify it.

The question of the existence of a supreme being vs random happenstance and having the forthright pragmatism to answer the question honestly tells me those recommendations were well deserved,,,,,
 
I've considered having the barrel of my .50 caliber LH Dixie Tenn Mtn rifle shortened to Hawken length. Just too long and cumbersome for hunting out of a blind or treestand. Plus, that front sight is so far down the barrel, it's invisible in low light.

The quick fix was purchasing a left-handed TC .54 caliber Renegade.............. one can never have too many rifles anyways.
 
While that buttplate extension may seem like an earlier feature, it was used in some schools, and on particularly fancy guns.


not as visible https://americanlongrifles.org/forum/index.php?topic=5564.0

I've seen other Shennefelts with more elaborate, and I think some of the NC guns have it. Its not easy to keep up with all of the makers/schools/etc.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ian
SNIP>>>
It’s .54, definitely *not* swamped, and at 42 inches, a bit heavy for free hand firing. The sights, though very fine T/C, and very good for hunting and target work, certainly lack period aesthetic. The patch box release needs help, I don’t much care for the design. And, to be quite honest, I prefer brass accoutrements. But, still and all, it’s a very fine rifle. I’ve not been able to track down the maker so far.

If I could wave a magic wand, I think cutting the barrel to 32” would make it much more shootable, and I can’t help but wonder if I would like it better as a flinter. Dovetail in a proper set of sights, finish coning and star’ing the muzzle. Have the 12” cut off made into a pistol, and live happily ever after.
I would respect Ian's opinion over my own.
With that said, I would consider shortening it, especially of you leave the Cap lock, trigger, and sights for off hand shooting. I don't know if those parts are modern TC, but they sure look like it from here. If they function as good as TC parts, I'd leave them and make the gun into a fancy shooter for off hand fun, I've never been one to enjoy benchrest shooting.
.
If that really has the potential of being a $3000 Rifle, then Winelover's opinion is what I would consider, I am a fan of TC.
Are all those silver colored inlays and accoutrements, sterling? or something less special?
.
When I first moved to Glencoe (1987), I was talked to by a fellow from the local Lodge. He hinted toward the idea that their membership was aging out and hoped I was interested (there wasn't much population growth in this area since 1950). Twenty two year old Jon didn't have any
knowledge of such a group, no family/friends/close acquaintances who was ever a member, there was no internet, so there was no easy way to learn a bit about them(admission: I was not much of a reader). The fellow wasn't offering much of a sales pitch to a young guy like me, so there was no interest, it ended there.
 
German silver, so gives the appearance, but doesn't turn black like coin silver. Its not the cost of the parts and materials, its the artistry and labor. I've seen contemporaries priced $15k and more.
 
In today's money it's at least $1200 in parts, maybe more depending on what the stock blank cost. The workmanship appears good, metal fit and finish is pretty close and the genral shaping and finish is good. The engraving and extra inlays add to the cost, but there is little carving so that reduces time involved. Custom longrifles start at about $3,000, and go up from there. You're looking at about 100-150 hours of labor depending on who did the work.
 
Yes they are T/C sights, and they made great rear sights. Patchbox, etc. look and feel like aluminum to me. Ian, as usual, I believe is right on the mark as far as cost. Previous owner (unknown if original) would not budge off of $1600.

I had forgotten I had posted this after buying it and trying to sus out a maker:


“The fellow wasn't offering much of a sales pitch to a young guy like me, so there was no interest, it ended there.”. In the old days, it was considered inappropriate to “advertise”, one was expected to be asked before answering any questions. And it hurt the fraternity.

300, thanks very much, that Kopp rifle certainly toes the mark! I notice keys instead of pins, this raises questions for me. I’ve had “Into the Bluegrass” by Hankla sitting here all Summer,,,,,
 
Last edited: