The Leather Part of the Handgun

Petrol & Powder

Well-Known Member
I am a strong believer that in the realm of handguns, the holster is a critical part of the system. A handgun without a holster is still useful but it sure is a LOT more useful with a holster.

In today’s world there is a huge array of synthetic material options. Materials such as Kydex, hard plastic, nylon, laminates, carbon fiber, and probably a dozen more are available. Those synthetic materials have their place and I’m not going to disparage them. However, I’m a bit old school, so most (not all) of my holsters and belts are leather.

Leather gear isn’t as maintenance free as the synthetic options, but I understand how to maintain leather gear and I’m willing to put in the work. I know many of the members of this forum make their own leather gear and that’s a skill I admire. I have neither the skill nor the tools to make leather gear. This lack of ability to make my own gear means I must purchase the gear I need. Fortunately, this isn’t a terrible predicament as there are plenty of good options in this field.

There are many holster makers ranging from mass producers, to semi-custom to one-of-a-kind craftsmen. We have no shortage of options here. Prices vary according to what one desires but again, it is good to have options. I have purchased and used leather gear from many different suppliers and overall, I’ve been very impressed with the cost versus quality ratio of the industry. You generally get what you pay for. When you look at the life span of good gear, it seems to be a decent value even in today’s world.

I recently purchased a leather holster from one of the larger producers. I will not mention the name of the company, but their initials are Galco. ;)

OK, jokes aside, it is a fairly good example of the quality available from one of the larger companies. In my opinion the price is commensurate with the quality. I did have to soak the holster in water and mold it a little to complete the fitting, but that’s not unusual for leather gear in that price range. After drying and a short break in, it fits the gun and me as it should.

I still find Don Hume leather gear to be one of the best values out there. I would probably use their gear exclusively if their line was a bit more extensive. I have even purchased used Don Hume gear and found it to be an excellent value.

DeSantis remains an east coast favorite of mine. Mitch Rosen gear is pricy but there’s no denying the quality. I used one of their 5JR thumb-break holsters daily for over ten years and I still use their belts daily. I was sad to see Bell Charter Oak close, they were one of those old-school, east coast suppliers that had a niche market for concealed carry rigs.

There are the old stand-by makers like Bianchi and Safariland (although Safariland is almost all synthetic gear these days). I had one of the early Milt Sparks Summer Special IWB rigs when they were almost unknown. I included that well-worn holster when I sold the 1911 Commander it held. Wished I had held onto the holster.

El Paso Saddlery continues to make excellent gear and they’ve never disappointed me. I have some odd ball holsters from makers that went out of business, and I have some custom-made gear from smaller one-man shops. Even Craft Holsters that are sold out of Slovakia but often marked Made in Italy, are good values, despite the shipping from the eastern hemisphere! (Their quality has impressed me).

So – even in today’s world of I-phones, internet, synthetic gun gear, plastic everywhere, computers everywhere, and hot filament type light blubs nearly being a black-market only item……..you can still get a quality leather holster!
 

Winelover

North Central Arkansas
Purchased an Azula (South Africa) LH leather holster off the other site for a 3" J-frame. With hopes, it would fit my 2 3/4" Bulldog. It did, just fine. When I wanted a LH cross draw for a S&W 24-3, that's what I purchased. Surprisingly, they had one in stock and delivered a few days later. Very well made, especially, for the price point.
 

JonB

Halcyon member
I don't think I've ever ordered a new leather holster?
Plenty of them have come with gun swaps, or a $5 box at a gunshow.
In my area, I can't think of another gun accessory that loses value as much?
Remember, I am in farm country in Minnesota, not to far from Minneapolis...so the area is highly suspect to this phenomenon.
Thinking as I typing this, maybe I need to start collecting them on the cheap, to flip to people who live in the real west, LOL.
 

RBHarter

West Central AR
There's a guy that goes by Drayton Calhoun that makes a few holsters. I have 3 of them , 2 for the 1858s and one for the Dragoon . 1 of them is pretty fancy for me .

I have a couple of Hunters and a basket weave Galco also .
Passive searches through the years have turned up some gems ...... probably knock offs . I have an officers polished probably 1911 intended flap holster that is almost perfect for the HP 9/P35/High Power.
My MIL recently picked up a flap holster that is a near perfect fit for the untouched 1917 . It's the same shape but otherwise nothing like the unmarked example Mom has for her Colts 1917 . I think it's stitched in sinew .
 

Elpatoloco

Active Member
I am with ya. I will not place any of my shooting irons in a plastic/synthetic holster.

I have leather from Junk to Custom made, wait a year on order type stuff.

I have settled on the Simply Rugged Holsters.

They are a great value for the money and designs are the most comfortable made IMHO.
 

JonB

Halcyon member
My MIL recently picked up a flap holster that is a near perfect fit for the untouched 1917 . It's the same shape but otherwise nothing like the unmarked example Mom has for her Colts 1917 . I think it's stitched in sinew .
I have (or had) a real old 1917 sized flap holster sewn with sinew, I think it came with a used cheapo 22LR revolver?
 

Rick H

Well-Known Member
When I worked I switched to Safariland almost exclusively for duty gear in 1985. Holster was for my Sig P220. When the department mandated a switch to Glocks in '92 I got a new Safariland holster and supporting gear for it. Yeah, it was synthetic, but seemed to function well until I retired in 2000. My duty rig has been hanging in my closet since I retired. A few years ago I heard a loud "clunk" and opened the closet to see that the cuff case (synthetic) just self destructed and crumbled. My cuffs had hit the floor. Checking the gear out the magazine pouch flaps were rotting as was the holster thumb break strap. The basic underbelt and gunbelt are leather and still in fine shape. I still have my original issue Bucheimer for a Model 19/66 S&W. The basketweave shows the scars of getting in and out of scout cars for years but it is fully functional. Circa 1975.

I like leather for most carry. Two exceptions: Inside waistband carry I use a kydex for my Shield. Kydex doesn't collapse or get sweat soaked and has been functional and comfortable for the past 10 yrs or so that I have used it. I also have a nylon "Uncle Mike's" cheapo nylon shoulder rig for the same S&W Shield 40. I use it when stream fishing. I float my hat at least a couple of times a year and the nylon gear is a lot easier to dry out.

I make some of my leather goods, and also have Galco, DeSantis, Don Hume, even an old "Jackass" shoulder rig for a 1911 Gov't model. I have an off the wall leather crossdraw paddle holster for my Ruger LCRx3 from a company in Southern Ohio, STONER HOLSTERs. It is a well made solid holster but finished with a garish shiny surface that looks like plastic. It isn't just a highly polished cordovan leather.

My preference is leather. I have to admit that synthetics have some qualities that make them preferable in certain situations. My old shop has gone exclusively to synthetics. Heavy nylon duty rigs. They also abandoned the old uniforms for stuff that looks like old gas station attendant clothing. I am not a fan of the paramilitary look for police officers.
 
Last edited:

RicinYakima

High Steppes of Eastern Washington
When I got outfitted for gear in LE in 1970, the department used Don Hume black leather stuff. I really liked the Jordan River Belt and holster. It was comfortable and very easy to care for in the heat and humidity of Ohio. However it would eat the bluing off of the Model 10 in just a couple of years since they were not lined.
1st day in LE uniform Cropped.jpg
 

RicinYakima

High Steppes of Eastern Washington
Below are my most commonly worn gun belts and holsters. The El Paso Saddlery Officer's belt has a Geo. Lawrence lined Model 120 "Keith" holster for a K frame target sighted six inch. There is also a Geo. Lawrence belt slide for another six rounds of 32/20. It is very comfortable walking in the sage brush or in the mountains.

The town rig is a Galco belt, SB2. sadly no longer made. And another Geo. Lawrence lined holster for the three inch S&W model 60-10 357. It only gets used when going down town or after dark and I'm wearing a coat.

holsters.jpg
 

Petrol & Powder

Well-Known Member
I'm not going to bash the synthetic materials; I think there’s a place for those newer materials. I will say that Rick H’s observations don’t surprise me – leather is a proven material and synthetics are the newer alternative.

The drawback of leather gear is the maintenance, something that younger generations seem to struggle with. The analogy that comes to mind for me is mechanical. I grew up in a world where trucks, tractors, cars, machinery, etc., had grease fittings. I knew what a Zerk fitting was at a young age because it was my job to take care of that maintenance. As I got older, sealed bearings, sealed tie rod ends, sealed ball joints, etc. became more prevalent. It always bothered me a little that you couldn’t grease those sealed bearings/ball joints/pivot points whatever. An older, and wiser mechanic explained the issue to me. He said, “if you know what a grease gun is and you use it like you should, you’ll be better off with greaseable bearings. But if you don’t own a grease gun, sealed bearings are your only chance”. I think synthetic materials are the parallel there.

If you take care of your leather gear – it will outlast you. But, if you’re a zero-maintenance kind of guy – synthetic materials are probably your only hope.
 

CZ93X62

Official forum enigma
I have about a 50/50 mix of leather and synthetic gunskin laying around. Bianchi, Safariland, Galco, and Michaels make up the herd here. Synthetic holsters are like Glock pistols--hell for stout (for a while) and utilitarian, and often costs less than leather. I have leather gear 45 years old that is almost as supple and just as comfy as it was when new. Sorry--leather is superior IMHO.

Where leather falls on its aspirations is in absorption of toxic elements in the environment. Leather cannot be de-contaminated; synthetics can be. My area of the PRK in the 1980s and 1990s had more drug labs extant than the rest of the country put together at that time, and a whole lot of leather gear worn by patrol deputies got barreled and stored at toxic waste sites in those days. I worked at Cal-DOJ's Clan Lab Task Force 1990-1992, and their webgear was all synthetic.

ETA--One of the most useful holsters and rigs I have and still use is a Bianchi UM-84 in black for the S&W & Beretta 5" pistols. It does a creditable securing most of my full-size autopistols, and it mounted on a black LC-1 belt and has an H-harness for heavier load-outs. It dates from 1987.
 
Last edited:

Petrol & Powder

Well-Known Member
I also have one of the older UM-84 holsters and it is a decent field holster for a full-sized pistol. Not the fastest rig by any stretch of the imagination but it was never intended to be fast. It is, however, secure and does a good job of protecting the pistol.

One thing I’ve noticed over the years is the lack of attention some folks pay to the selection of a holster. They get the left- or right-hand decision, they usually get a holster that sort of fits the required gun, but the attention seems to taper off after those decisions. Details such as high ride/mid ride/low ride are often not considered. The straight drop, forward cant or rearward cant seems to be lost of some buyers. And the retention devices, if any, are not considered by many users. There’s a lot more to selecting a holster than, “does it fit the gun”.
 

JWinAZ

Active Member
A different appeal for a holster. Made for me by a friend. He learned leather work from his dad who was a saddle maker at Wallace's Cowboy Outfitters in Tucson. I asked for it to be lined, with hammer strap, and simple embellishment. It is secure and I have worn it a few times, but mostly it is a memento with good memories.

Single Six Holster.jpg