I've had a bunch of 1911 pistols over the years including a few Colt Commanders from Hartford that had the prancing pony on the side.
One was a brand-new lightweight Commander from the Colt Custom shop. That pistol was the most overpriced piece of junk I ever owned and I was happy to see it go down the road. Another was a stainless-steel Colt Combat Commander (all steel) that was sort of average. And the third was a used early 1970’s vintage, blued, lightweight Commander that was a great pistol. I foolishly sold that one to buy the Custom Shop model. (mistake)
I like the concept of the Commander length slide (4.25” barrel). That “Commander” sized pistol is seen replicated throughout the world of carry pistols in models such as the Glock 19/23, SIG 225/228, and countless others. The pattern includes enough grip to hold onto, enough barrel length & sight radius for good shooting, but not too big overall. It’s a good compromise in size, capacity, power, and accuracy for a carry gun.
For a carry pistol, the lightweight frame is the way to go. That is the classic – carried a lot, shot a little, platform.
If you are going to put a lot of rounds through the gun, the steel frame models are the way to go. If you are going to put a lot of rounds through the gun and it will mainly be a range/target gun – the full size 5” slide gives you a little more sight radius and mass.
I’m hoping that CZ can right the ship and bring some value back to the Colt name. In the meantime, there are far better options in the 1911 arena.