Favorite Press

CWLONGSHOT

Well-Known Member
We all have them. I venture most are like me and have had many.

I have always like the Rock Chucker and have swayed and returned a few times. I still own my very first. My fathers Spartan and have a representative of the first I learned upon.( The Lyman JR). I have about a dozen and like parts of all of them . I have a good friend who has suggested I sell
Off all those under the bench and buy a Area 419. (1300$ retail!!!) This is because he views it as the best. Maybe because its so expensive? I dont know, I have considered it, but know big $$ dont ensure the best just as buying a "new" part doesn't always correct a problem.

But... I do have a desire for the MEC Marksman. ;) This press impresses me.

SO, Id like to know your opinions. You guys collectively always seem to cast light to dark corners for me.

What is your favorite.

What is one you would like to try?

CW
 

glassparman

"OK, OK, I'm going as fast as I don't want to go!"
I have my fathers CH "C style" press from the 70's and a Spartan but the Rock Chucker is the strongest for swaging cartridge conversions IMHO.

I also have a vintage Lyman Tru-Line only because it has optional priming rods for the old 1/4" Berdan primers.

I love my Rock Chucker and use it for most everything. It even made it through the shop fire.
 

Petrol & Powder

Well-Known Member
Wow, Favorite Press, that's a tough assignment to pick only one.

Until a few years ago, I would likely have said Rock Chucker. I had one and sold it years ago. If there was ever an iconic single stage press, the Rock Chucker is it.

Long story and I will not re-tell it here, but along the way I ended up with a RCBS Reloader Special 5 that made the move between a few houses. That economy, aluminum frame, budget press turned out to be a surprisingly good press. It eventually was sold to a co-worker.
Had several other presses along the way. Still have a spare RCBS JR3 tucked away just in case an asteroid hits the earth or some new “supply chain” issue crops up.

I took a chance on the new RCBS Rebel, and I am happy to say that it is every bit as good as the old Rock Chucker.
So, I would have to say the RCBS Rebel is my favorite.
 

Jeff H

NW Ohio
The original LEE, 3-hole Turret Press!

If I were starting out today, I'd probably go for the 4-hole, but it's not worth switching now.

Like Brian, my experience started at my Dad's bench well over fifty years ago. He had a Lyman Comet, another brutish single-stage I forget the name of and three or four Tru-Line Jrs. I've also used a lot of other presses belongingto others while helping them get stafrted or work out some kind of bug. MAYBE, the Tru-Line Jrs. influenced my ultimate choice more, but a fine gentleman who owned a gun shop in Salinas steered me right when I was 2000+ miles from Dad's bench and on my own. Kim was that fine fellow's name, and I believe @462 knows who I'm talking about.

I was stationed at the Presidio of Monterey, young buck sergeant, with an emphasis on young - and not making a lot of money, living in an apartment. I went into Kim's shop looking for a Lyman or RCBS press, cast-iron. I had just paid $17 for my first and LAST box of factory 44 Special and had to do something about it. Kim very deftly turned me in another direction and sold me on that LEE press, ostensibly for economy's sake, rationalizing that I could always upgrade later. $48 for that press. That allowed me to buy an RCBS reloaidng kit with a 505 scale, Uniflow measure, deburring tool, Speer manual and various other small peripherals, PLUS a pound of Unique, 500 commercially cast bullets and some primers for not much over $100.

Long story short, that was in '82 and about '90 or so I "upgraded" to a big-name, cast-iron press. After about a year, I ditched it and went back to the LEE, three-hole Turret Press. Low-mass, low-inertia, smooth, operation is effortless, great clearance and the turrets are compact and allow me to have sets of dies all set up and ready to go. If I start to seat a bullet and realize I missed one during flaring, I can twist the turret 120 degrees, flare, twist back and get back to seating. It's no different than working on a single-stage except for that and that I don't have to set each die each time I load a given cartridge.

If I had to, I could dismount that press, tape a piece of cardboard on the bottom and reload by holding it against a bench with my off hand - just like I did when living in apartments in the military. That brings me to the ONE flaw I see in this press, which is spent primers, which accumulate to the point that you eventually have to dismount the press to empty the reservoir. Problem solved - I recently mounted it to a 1" thick piece of PVC sheet and have a threaded coupler/plug I will cement in place on the bottom when I get a few spare minutes.

I'm down to FIVE dies sets now, meaning five loaded turrets and a couple with various other dies, like the flaring die and universal decapper, couple collet factory crimp dies. I like to keep things simple and this press works well for that. I've used a lot of presses, but I just think the world of this one - its the most ingenious press ever made.

I also have a LEE "O-type," single stage I use for sizing bullets, for which I paid $15 or $20 new, back in the early nineties, on sale. I recently got a LEE Breech-Lock hand-press for a portable kit, which I am also fond of. It may seem like I'm brand-loyal, or just a skin-flint either, as I've chosen these presses carefully, giving all others a thorough look and simply find that these presses make me happy, especially the older Turret Press.

EDIT: Sorry this was that long, but I really did compress it as much as I am capable.
 
Last edited:

fiver

Well-Known Member
dunno, really.
i wore out my first rock chucker and had to have a new slightly oversize ram made for it.
i had it made threaded for swaging, so it doesn't get used for reloading anymore.

the Rebel is just there, it isn't a favorite by any means, but seems to be my main bullet seating press for larger rifle loading.
the Lyman is sturdy for sure but always seems to have the Dillon trimmer on it.
the junior got moved out to the garage, pretty much only gets used to make 223 bullets for my varmint rifle, and does a little bit of sizing powder coated bullets.
the 550 on the right seems to load the most variety of ammo, the one next to it maybe the highest volume of the 4.
the other rock chucker only seems to load some of this and some of that from time to time, and mostly gets used to de-prime stuff even though it has it's own dedicated powder dump and scale,, it's nice and shiny and tight.

i really think my Favorite press is the L/S-1000 made by Ponsess Warren, i've completely worn out two trap guns with it and only had to replace the plastic bushings in it once, actually only the one needed replaced but since i was there..
 

Jeff H

NW Ohio
.....buy a Area 419. (1300$ retail!!!) This is because he views it as the best. Maybe because its so expensive?....

CW

No offense to your buddy - or to anyone, but what could anyone possibly do to a press to make it worth that much more than any run o' th' mill press? Realistically, unless a press is really, really BAD, it's GOOD. Precision? How precise is the shell-holder or the means by which it is attached? How precise is the brass we manage to scrounge?

I've shot some amazing groups from ammo loaded on cheap LEE presses, with all kinds of "wiggle-room," this way and that, particularly with the turrets. I don't know about others here, but chasing "tenths" in groups is a hobby in itself and really means nothing when we're hunting - even hunting tiny stuff at a quarter mile.

BLUNT OLD MAN WARNING!

That $1300 is going to buy you prestige and "cred' " among people who's opinions don't matter anyway.

Brian, I know YOU'RE smarter than that, but that little diatribe was welling up and spilling over. I HAD to say it. I'm playin' the friend-card in hope of forgiveness for polluting your thread with cranky old-guy blather.
 
Last edited:

fiver

Well-Known Member
yeah,,, everything they make is expensive, i dunno if the return on the investment is worth the upfront cost.
i'd eyeball a Harrell's or Corbin before i dropped the money on their stuff,,, heck i'd look to an arbor press and squish dies too.l
3-4-500 dollars is one thing..
 

CWLONGSHOT

Well-Known Member
Haha Worry not Jeff. I WAS COUNTING on some tongue lashing!!
I was honest when I said I thought about it. But honest too when I said what cannot do another good press I likely already have cannot!

(I would like a MEC!!)

All opinion welcome! I KNOW IAN HAS SOME ADVICE!!

CW
 

fiver

Well-Known Member
not Ian, but he'll tell you all about rebuilding 3 LEE's starting with a sand casting and a box of light switches.

that Mec is impressive.
to tell the truth my next press [rolling my eyes, i just gave 2 to my SIL] would be a LEE classic cast.
 

RicinYakima

High Steppes of Eastern Washington
Because of my physical issues, using a "pull up handle" press is a real pain. So my most used press is the RCBS Summit and an arbor press with Wilson hand dies. Loved the 1950's original Redding press, but everything has to be shop made if you don't have original tooling.
 

JWinAZ

Active Member
Mine are Rock Chucker and Pacific C presses. My pet peeve is primers falling to the floor. Even with the catcher they will bounce out and disappear under the bench. Thinking about the Forster Co-Ax. What is the consensus? Will it work with smaller pistol cartridges such as .32 Long?
 

Bret4207

At the casting bench in the sky. RIP Bret.
Bonanza CoAx. I don't load anything that's long enough to cause problems and I don't do much case forming. The CoAx is just a sweet machine to run. I also like my Lyman Spar T. Its a s close to a progressive as I've gotten and make loading revolver rounds easier for me.
 

462

California's Central Coast Amid The Insanity
Kim was that fine fellow's name, and I believe @462 knows who I'm talking about.
Yep, Kim Piser owner of Trigger Hill -- full-service gun, reloading, and gunsmithing. Kim was a laid-back gentleman and gentle man who died several months ago.

He sold the store sometime round the turn of the century to a guy who ran it into the ground, defrauded consignees, and ended up in prison.

Back on topic; I narrowed my presses down to an RCBS JR 3 and a Lee Classic Cast 4-hole turret. The JR is used for pulling bullets and ram priming, the Lee for one-press convenience but not speed.
 

Rick H

Well-Known Member
I have owned a Redding Boss(?) for about 35 yrs. It is a solid, dare I say bullet proof, single stage reloading press. It is my most used press and my favorite. I have a newer cast iron Lee 4 holer classic, a 3 hole basic turret and a single stage. All get used but not favorites. My first reloading press was a Lyman Spar-T turret. I still have it, but it lives in quiet retirement
 
Last edited:

CWLONGSHOT

Well-Known Member
I also had a BOSS. I didnt like those flat bars. they got in the way.

(CORRECTION: Not a Boss but a ULTRA MAG press. I always confused the names of these two presses.)

I also had a Bonanza but older before Forster and its universal shell plate/holder.

I also have a lil LEE 4 holer that I like for what it is a pistol press. I dislike most LEE presses. But that Classic Cast thats as good a press as anyones.

Even my Frankfort M Press (since rebuild) has been good to me.

My ol' Pacfic O press is a dandy!

I retired the M-Press (You guys knew it would not be long) and replaced on old bicycle gripped, Rock Chucker I repainted it silver. (What I had at the time) The lizard green coating was peeling off. Pressure washer removed rest if is pretty easily.

CW
 
Last edited:

RBHarter

West Central AR
I have a bunch of presses a Pacific casting Hornady red probably holds the most sentimental attachment . There's an RCBS RS and several Lyman's and another Pacific DeLuxe I need to trade off for the Super De Luxe so I can use the 30 cal 100-110 gr RN HP swage dies . I have a Partner that is just about used up .

I load lots of pistol ammo 1 at a time on singles. The thing is I love the RC and RCII but they are just too much for press for 380 , 9mm 40 etc . You know which one I love even more than the RC's ? The Big Max A4 . That thing is a tank and it's absolutely no problem at all to make a 6.5 CM a 6.5×50SR in a half stroke relube run it up all the way , and shove most of the head bulge into the extractor groove . Unfortunately it's like driving an F900 to with a 18' deck to the Mall on Black Friday for any loading 30-30 and smaller . Also the universal claw isn't big enough for 45-70 and I don't think it would hold 30-30 either ....... Not a big deal the universal shell holder adapter works fine .
 

Winelover

North Central Arkansas
Started out with the RCBS JR (kit form) in the 70's. Only press for many years. Still gets the most use. Relegated to pistol caliber reloading since I got the eight station Hollywood Senior Turret.

The Hollywood isn't for decapping or priming or as a turret, perse. It's set up with expanding and seating dies for the rifle rounds I load the most. So, basically a single stage that indexes.



Hollywood Press 6.jpg